TheTrenchcoat Chronicles

Odgren’s lawyer wants indictment thrown out

Written by

Trench Reynolds

in

Odgren attorney: Throw out first-degree murder indictment:

Criminal defense attorneys never fail to amuse me. Take for instance the attorney to John Odgren, Jonathan Shapiro. Mr. Shapiro wants the first-degree murder indictment against his client because the prosecution did not instruct the grand jury properly as to Odgren’s mental and psychological conditions.

For those of you just joining us a then 16-year-old Odgren is accused of stabbing 15-year-old James Alenson to death in a bathroom at Lincoln-Sudbury Regional High School. Alenson was allegedly chosen at random by Odgren. Odgren has been diagnosed with Aspergers Syndrome which some think that Odgren was not responsible for his own actions. To which I say bullshit.

Aspergers does not cause someone to become randomly violent and to claim such will only make people with Asperger’s outcast and reviled probably more than they already are. Asperger’s did not make John Odgren plan this murder months in advance. Asperger’s did not put the knife into John Odgren’s hand.

So in my unprofessional opinion, I think the prosecution absolutely did the right thing by not disclosing his alleged mental deficiencies to the grand jury. To do so would be almost criminal.

Comments

20 responses to “Odgren’s lawyer wants indictment thrown out”

  1. BelchSpeak Avatar
    BelchSpeak

    Nope, but I heard it makes you a virgin. And a bedwetter. And bi-curious.

    Reply
  2. Trench Avatar
    Trench

    Only in one case that we know of.

    Reply
  3. Endersdragon Avatar
    Endersdragon

    You never get old… until now…

    Reply
  4. Trench Avatar
    Trench

    What? No insightful commentary on how Odgren isn’t responsible.

    Reply
  5. Endersdragon Avatar
    Endersdragon

    I have already given you stories of Asperger’s causing violence, if you don’t believe them yet you never will. Why should I keep on trying?

    Reply
  6. Endersdragon Avatar
    Endersdragon

    And what is the harm of giving someone all the facts not just those they consider relevant? Shouldn’t the grand jury be allowed to decide what is relevant or not?

    Reply
  7. ZappaCrappa Avatar
    ZappaCrappa

    Cool…Enders says your getting old…it must be true coming from the ass…errrrr…mouth of the twenty something year old expert in everything from mental health, the complete judicial system, the complete prison system, the economic system, the complete educational system, male to female AND male to male realationships….oh….and firearms…..did I miss anything? I apologize if I did…

    Reply
  8. Endersdragon Avatar
    Endersdragon

    I am not calling myself an expert, I am just wondering wheres the harm in giving them all the facts. And seeing as how you can’t answer the question can I assume there is none? He has a condition that has been known to cause violence in some cases, why not tell them about it.

    Reply
  9. ZappaCrappa Avatar
    ZappaCrappa

    I’m not talking about now…I’m talking about your history. You are a know it all.

    Reply
  10. Endersdragon Avatar
    Endersdragon

    So you don’t care to answer my question, just to insult me. Well isn’t that off topic Trench?

    Reply
  11. Trench Avatar
    Trench

    So is asking about a 9-year-old from a different post. What’s your point?

    Reply
  12. Endersdragon Avatar
    Endersdragon

    Just prefer fair and equitable treatment, I have been banned for supposedly going off-topic before and as far as I know there has never been a topic here specifically for making fun of someone.

    Reply
  13. BelchSpeak Avatar
    BelchSpeak

    What’s wrong with stating all the facts? I keep doing that about you. Stating all the facts about you so others can understand your angle and where you get your questionable opinions. That way when other people see that you are a virgin chronic bedwetter who laughs out loud maniacally when alone and wants to give oral sex to other boys, they can understand why you want child killers to be personally counseled by you. Just throwing all the facts in there. Like a giant fact stew. Zappa can add to this stew too, as too many cooks can’t spoil a fact soup. No, too many facts doesn’t muddy the waters or confuse any issues… facts are just facts and as long as they are out there, we might as well get all of them.

    Reply
  14. Trench Avatar
    Trench

    Anecdotal stories if I recall.

    Reply
  15. Trench Avatar
    Trench

    Well, I kind of make the rules up depending on my mood. But I guess you’ve figured that out by now. You should thank Belch by the way. He’s the one that requested your unbanning.

    Reply
  16. Endersdragon Avatar
    Endersdragon

    Facts and libel are too totally different things. I did bedwet for a while, big deal millions of Americans have. Virgin, you have no evidence of this so be quiet until you come up with some. Pedophile, you have absolutely no evidence of this, so see above. I don’t think I ever used the word manically or alone when describing my laughter problems from about 5-7 years ago I believe. So if your going to put all the facts out there at least put them in context.

    Odgren has a diagnosis of asperger’s, this has been used as a defense in other cases, and has lead to violence before, thats putting the information in context.

    Reply
  17. BelchSpeak Avatar
    BelchSpeak

    I didn’t say anything about you being a pedo- that must be a freudian slip on your part. And I didn’t think that assburpers made people violent thanks for clearing that up.

    Reply
  18. Endersdragon Avatar
    Endersdragon

    You have implied it in the past Belchy so I always assume you will imply it again. And asperger’s doesn’t always make people violent, but there have been cases where its happened in the past, particularly with younger ones. Though I also assume many AS kids will develop PTSD from how society treats them like shit so it could be that too. Fact is only one boy knows what happened in there and hes not too trustworthy.

    Reply
  19. BelchSpeak Avatar
    BelchSpeak

    Hmmm… Violent when young, violent when old, and totally creepy in the middle. You make a great argument for internment.

    Reply
  20. Endersdragon Avatar
    Endersdragon

    I never said anything other then sometimes violent when younger. Remember PTSD doesn’t neccessarily equal violent either. And creepy is a matter of opinion, mainly yours. So what exactly was your point again.

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Trench Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More posts