Tag: depositions

Archives vanishing act:

This is an editorial from Rocky Mountain News that gives some great reasons for making the depositions of the Columbine killers’ parents public…

The Rocky, along with several families of the victims, have repeatedly called for the depositions to be made public. They offer the only sworn statements from the killers’ parents that could reveal what they knew about the boys before their murderous spree – including what information they shared with school or law enforcement officials in advance.

Disclosing these records would reopen many wounds. But it could also provide insights that could warn others.

If Babcock is not inclined simply to release the depositions – the best option, in our view – in part because of privacy concerns, there is an alternative. The judge could order the depositions sealed in the archives until the deaths of the Harrises and the Klebolds.

This would allow some additional aspects of the tragedy to eventually be explained. And anything that casts more light on the thinking of the killers and those who knew them best, however belated the disclosure, is a goal worth pursuing.

That definitely makes a lot more sense than sending the depositions to the National Archives for 25 years only to be destroyed. Normally I’m not conspiracy minded but between Sheriff Ted Mink and now Judge Babcock it seems like that all law enforcement and all those involved seem to be covering something up.

Judge: Seal Columbine papers for 25 years:

U.S. District Court Judge Lewis Babcock has suggested that the depositions given by the parents of Columbine killers Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold should be sent to the National Archives and be kept sealed for 25 years.

In 2002, the parents of Columbine killer Eric Harris gave more than 16 hours of depositions in connection with a lawsuit by Columbine survivor Mark Taylor against Solvay Pharmaceuticals, maker of Luvox.

Taylor claimed that Luvox, an anti-depressant, made Harris homicidal and suicidal. However, Taylor dropped the lawsuit in February 2003 after Solvay agreed to contribute $10,000 to the American Cancer Society.

The other depositions of Harris’ parents and the parents of Dylan Klebold took place over a four-day period in August 2003 in connection with a lawsuit filed by the families of five slain Columbine students. But, like the Solvay lawsuit depositions, the depositions were sealed when those families reached a settlement with the Harris and Klebold families.

The depositions have since been sitting in a highly secured evidence room at the federal courthouse awaiting a decision by Babcock about what should be done with them.

After 25 years, the National Archives would decide if the depositions are of significant social value and could release them to the public. Otherwise, they’d be destroyed, according to evidence presented at today’s hearing.

Babcock said he wouldn’t make a final decision until all sides had an opportunity to file written responses with him. He gave the parties a two-week deadline to file motions.

I understand that depositions in privately settled lawsuits are supposed to remain sealed but this is a special case. I’ll be honest with you. I can think of no legal reason why the depositions should be made public. I only want to see the released for my own personal curiosity. In my opinion, it’s already been proven that the Harrises dropped the parenting ball. I just want to see how many opportunities they had to prevent the massacre but didn’t.