Category: School Violence

  • Opening Testimony in Rocori High Shooting

    Opening Testimony in Rocori High Shooting

    Testimony begins in Rocori court case:

    Yesterday testimony began in the trial of John Jason McLaughlin, who is charged with shooting and killing two of his classmates, Seth Bartell and Aaron Rollins, at Rocori High School in Cold Spring, Minnesota.

    I can’t do the article justice, so please read the entire article.

    Basically, what it comes down to is, the prosecution is saying that McLaughlin was teased to the breaking point about his acne and suffered from some kind of mental illness.

    In my opinion, the only mental disorder that he had is that he’s a psychopath. According to reports, he shot Seth Bartell once in the side then followed him up a flight of stairs then shot him once more through the forehead. Here’s a chilling quote about that…

    Much of McGee’s testimony Tuesday was set against the backdrop of a projection screen that showed autopsy pictures and other images, including Bartell’s last school yearbook photo. In the picture, Bartell is wearing a hat that his mother said he talked school staff into letting him wear for the picture, something that normally would be prohibited under school rules, she said.

    That was the kind of boy Seth was, she said: able to get his way with a dose of charm. The Bartells saw that hat again Tuesday, only this time it was in McGee’s hands. He used it to show a half-inch hole in the brim, the spot through which McLaughlin fired his final, fatal shot.

    All because of acne. The thought processes of some of these kids are downright frightening.

  • McLaughlin waives jury trial for one charge

    McLaughlin waives jury trial for one charge

    Teen waives jury trial in Cold Spring killings: (Log in info)

    In an unusual turn of events for these kinds of cases, John Jason McLaughlin has waived his right to jury trial for the second-degree murder charge in the death of Aaron Rollins. The article doesn’t give too much information outside of that, but I’m assuming that he will still face a jury in the charge of first-degree murder in the death of Seth Bartell. In case you forgot from yesterday…

    McLaughlin allegedly shot Bartell in a basement hallway in front of other students, wounding him superficially in the chest, then fired a second shot that missed Bartell but hit Rollins in the neck. Bartell fled up some stairs. McLaughlin pursued Bartell into the gym and shot him in the forehead, prosecutors say.

    The defense is trotting out the usual…

    Attorney Dan Eller has said McLaughlin only intended to wound Bartell, who he thought had been teasing him, and that Rollins was not his intended target.

    Again, not a valid reason to shoot an unarmed person in the chest, chase him up a flight of stairs and shoot him in the head. If he was just trying to wound him, he wouldn’t have shot him through his skull.

    And the myth continues to perpetuate.

  • John Jason McLaughlin

    John Jason McLaughlin

    It just goes to show you that I am not the authority on the subject, nor am I omniscient. This is a story that has eluded my notice for the past year and a half.

    On Sept 24, 2003, 15-year-old John Jason McLaughlin shot two of his fellow students at Rocori High School in Cold Spring, Minnesota. The victims were Aaron Rollins, 17, who was shot in the neck and died later that day in the hospital and the intended target Seth Bartell, 14, who was shot in the chest and head. Bartell held on for 16 days before passing away.

    Here’s how the suspect was originally described back in 2003…

    But lately, those who know McLaughlin said, he began to change. He seemed more withdrawn and didn’t want to come out to play. Some described him as intensely shy and self-conscious about his severe acne.

    “It really was this summer that things seemed different,” Jess Phillips, 12, who lives about a block away, told the Star Tribune.

    Neil Wackwitz, 15, who was perhaps his closest friend in the neighborhood, also told the newspaper said McLaughlin seemed to withdraw this summer.

    Sullivan said she noticed lately that he didn’t seem to have many other friends. She wondered whether his small size or his acne played a role.

    “Kids would tease him about that,” she said.

    Wackwitz said he and McLaughlin used to play video or computer games or hang out. But lately, McLaughlin usually said he didn’t want to. He also started walking home after school instead of riding the bus.

    Wackwitz said he felt bad but didn’t think anything was seriously wrong. He said McLaughlin never mentioned that anything or anyone was bugging him. In particular, he said, McLaughlin never complained to him that kids at school were picking on him.

    Sullivan said that McLaughlin had mentioned to her that people were picking on him but that he didn’t seem too concerned about it.

    But she said there were signs that something was amiss. During one of their long chats, she recalled, McLaughlin told her that he was being tested this summer for a split-personality disorder. She said he never mentioned it again.

    Others also said that teasing may have been the motive behind the shooting. However…

    If Jason McLaughlin brought a gun to school because he was tired of the teasing, classmates say they can’t figure out why he targeted Seth Barthell and Aaron Rollins.

    Those two boys, according to Richter, were not among the kids who teased McLaughlin.

    “I think his main target was some other kid,” he says.

    In July 2004, McLaughlin pleaded not guilty under the defense that he did not intend to kill Seth Bartell and that his mental state was in question at the time. Previously, a grand jury had determined that Aaron Rollins was shot accidentally by McLaughlin.

    McLaughlin was to be tried as an adult. His attorney appealed, but in November 2004, the appeal was denied. (Log in info)

    And after almost two years, the trial is finally starting to get underway.

    I’ll be keeping an eye on this one.

    If anyone has any more information that I missed, please let me know.

  • Osantowski Verdict Aftermath

    Osantowski Verdict Aftermath

    Michigan teen guilty of making threats to attack school:

    (Log in info) Andrew Osantowski’s defense attorney, Brian Legghio, continues to crack me up…

    Defense attorney Brian Legghio said he plans to file an appeal after the sentencing arguing, among other things, the cache of weapons discovered in Osantowski’s home should have not been admissible as evidence. Prosecutors did not have to prove Osantowski had the capability or the intent to carry out a threat, he said, and called that evidence prejudicial.

    “When you peel that away, all you’re left with is a text message,” said Legghio, who doubted the message alone would have been enough to get a conviction.

    He added that he would “bet my bar card” that the conviction would be overturned on appeal.

    I would love to take that bet. Osantowski pleaded guilty to the stolen weapons charge, so why shouldn’t it have been presented as evidence? Why is it prejudicial if it’s fact?

    What is also very interesting is this quote from Chippewa Valley Superintendent Mark Deldin…

    “There probably would have been some fear in our community if he had gone back home, in our neighborhoods,” Deldin said. “But I think the biggest message that this verdict sends today goes beyond Chippewa Valley Schools. It’s a resounding message that threats of violence and terrorism in our schools will not be tolerated.”

    Emphasis mine.

    That’s a great point. This case should have gotten more media attention than it did. This case should serve as a warning to those who would entertain the thought of attacking their school that this is their fate. I hope the sentencing phase drives home that point as well.

  • Osantowski found guilty

    Osantowski found guilty

    Macomb County teen found guilty of threatening terrorism:

    A jury found Andrew Osantowski guilty of threatening an act of terrorism and using a computer to threaten terrorism. Each charge is punishable by up to 20 years in prison. Sentencing is set to take place on July 11.

  • Arrogance

    Arrogance

    Trial ends for terror suspect:

    This is another article about the Andrew Osantowski trial. It doesn’t provide much more information than already given, but a couple of the paragraphs regarding Andrew Osantowski’s attorney, Brian Legghio, made my jaw drop…

    Legghio, however, voiced some doubt about the authenticity or completeness of McGinty’s record of the chats as submitted to her father; he also likened himself to fictional Atticus Finch for defending a marginal and unpopular client and compared his client to Japanese Americans during World War II or blacks in the old South.

    Legghio said the teen was misguided or a geek, who probably needs therapy. He said Osantowski did not show any intent to coerce civilians or the government.

    “That’s the most important element,” Legghio told the jury in closings. “Otherwise, by God you can just forget your free speech, because you aren’t going to have any left.”

    Emphasis mine.

    Could this guy be any more arrogant? And here I thought doctors were the only ones with God complexes. I guess criminal defense attorneys do too.

  • Osantowski Trial Concludes

    Osantowski Trial Concludes

    Jury weighs terror, firearm charges against teen:

    I guess I watch too much Law & Order. I was expecting a longer trial. The trial for Andrew Osantowski on terror charges ended yesterday, and the jury will deliberate on his fate today. I guess that’s what they mean by your right to a speedy trial. However, the way juries have been acting lately, I’m not getting my hopes up on a conviction.

  • Osantowski claims bullying. I claim bullshit

    Osantowski claims bullying. I claim bullshit

    Teen accused of plotting massacre at high school said he was bullied:

    According to this Associated Press article Andrew Osantowski claims he was bullied in his IM chat with Celia McGinty. In the partial chat transcript that’s been released the only thing he says about bullying is…

    nazi_bot_sadistic:(expletive) bullied…made fun of….pushed….people can get away with murder

    So I call bullshit on the Associated Press. Not to mention the fact that Andrew Osantowski attended Chippewa Valley High School for 10 days before he was arrested. How can you have so much hatred for a school in such a small amount of time? I doubt he got the idea to shoot up a school in just 10 days. This is more telling as why he wanted to shoot up a school…

    “I’m going to bring nightmares back to everyone, roam the land as a ghost still killing people,” Osantowski wrote. “I’ll have followers. I’ll be famous too.”

    Just another mutant.

    Celia McGinty was supposed to have testified today against Osantowski but…

    “She really doesn’t want to see (Osantowski) face-to-face,” assistant Macomb County prosecutor Steve Kaplan said.

    Can you blame her?

    Her father, Sgt. George McGinty, a Washington State University policeman, did testify saying that…

    …his daughter left a printout of Osantowski’s messages with him while he was sleeping. He said he took it to work, read it and asked co-workers to follow-up with Michigan authorities.

  • Opening Statements in Osantowski Trial

    Opening Statements in Osantowski Trial

    Lawyer: No criminal act by teen accused of threatening terrorism:

    The opening statements in Andrew Osantowski’s trial were today.

    First up, defense attorney turned comedian Brian Legghio…

    The lawyer for a 17-year-old accused of plotting a massacre at his suburban Detroit high school said Friday that the teenager is angry, hurt and foolish, but isn’t guilty of threatening an act of terrorism.

    “He might belong in therapy. He might need psychotropic drugs. But what he did when he communicated with this girl was not a criminal act,” defense attorney Brian Legghio said during his opening statement at Andrew Osantowski’s trial.

    That’s the best you’ve got? Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, my client is a psychotic nut job in possession of stolen firearms, but in no way did he threaten to blow up that school. Um..yeah…sure.

    Next up, assistant county prosecutor Steve Kaplan…

    But assistant county prosecutor Steve Kaplan told the 14 jurors that Internet messages sent by Osantowski violated state laws against threatening an act of terrorism and using a computer to make threats of terrorism.

    “This is not a crime of terrorism. The crime is making a threat of terrorism, not committing terrorism,” Kaplan said. “The facts really are not in dispute.”

    It’s hard to argue with that.

    Celia McGinty, the Idaho girl who reported the threats made in a chat with Osantowski, is expected to testify on Monday.

  • Osantowski Pleads Guilty to Firearms Charges

    Osantowski Pleads Guilty to Firearms Charges

    Teen accused of planning an attack pleads guilty to firearms charges:

    Andrew Osantowski pleaded guilty to three counts of receiving and concealing firearms. And again my favorite lawyer turned comedian, Brian Legghio had some funny things to say…

    Legghio said Thursday’s guilty pleas do not prove Osantowski planned to use the guns, an AK-47 assault rifle and two pump shotguns stolen from a local firearms dealer. He also said the terrorism law under which his client is being prosecuted may violate free speech rights.

    “Can you criminalize speech just because you don’t like what somebody says?” Legghio said.

    No, but when someone says they’re going to kill their family, then shoot up the school, it’s no longer free speech. Especially since that person was found with an AK-47 assault rifle and two pump shotguns. And yeah, he didn’t plan to use the stolen guns. He was going to give them back your honor, honest. Whatever.

    My favorite part is that Legghio motioned to get the chat transcripts amended to say “Andrew” instead of Osantowski’s username “nazi_bot_sadistic”. The judge rejected that motion. Go figure.

    The prosecution doesn’t seem to be fazed by the guilty plea…

    Kaplan said his case was helped by Osantowski’s admission that he knowingly possessed stolen firearms. “If he tries to commit an act of terrorism, he needs something more than a slingshot,” the prosecutor said during jury selection.

    And as far as sentencing goes…

    The felony firearm charge carries a 2-year mandatory sentence. Each firearm charge to which Osantowski pleaded guilty is a felony punishable by up to 10 years in prison, but Switalski said he would not set a sentencing date until after the remainder of the case was tried.

    More on this as it develops.